Robert Parker Wine Advocate im Feb. 2013: ''Gorgeous, flowery, classic Margaux once again, the 2010 Malescot St.-Exupery continues to show virtually no toasty oak, given the impeccable balance and full-bodied, full-throttle style it possesses. Black raspberries, creme de cassis and spring floral notes intermixed with forest floor and a hint of charcoal are followed by an opulent, sexy, full-bodied wine whose tannins have become much sweeter, while the wine is less restrained yet still exuberant and impressive. This is a phenomenal example once again for this estate, harmonious in every sense of style, extraordinarily long, rich and ageworthy. Three to four years of bottle age will do wonders to make it more accessible, but this wine is set for 25-30 years of longevity. '' Weinwisser (www.weinwisser.com) im Juni 2011: ''Extrem dunkles Purpur. Vielschichtiges, parfümiertes Bouquet, Holunderblüten, Brombeeren, Heidelbeeren, tolle Tiefe. Feiner Gaumen, seidige Tannine, blaue und schwarze Beeren, gut stützende Säure, was dem Wein auch eine imposante Länge beschert. Wieder auf Top-Niveau wie schon letztes Jahr.''